Send us a text

Why Your Lead Gen Strategy Isn't Working And the Smarter Approach Established Coaches Actually Need

If your lead generation strategy feels like you are pushing water uphill, sliding into DMs, showing up in Facebook groups, going to networking events, doing everything you were told to do and the discovery calls are still not coming, you are not broken. You are using the wrong strategy for where you actually are. Lead generation for coaches at your level is not about volume. It is about precision. And this episode names exactly what is getting in the way.

In This Episode

I open with the specific frustration I see in almost every established founder I work with: the effort-to-results ratio that makes no sense. You are showing up. You are putting in the work. And yet the calendar stays emptier than it should, which quietly fuels the belief that something is wrong with you or that business is just hard.

I unpack why cold outreach, while not wrong for every business, is fundamentally misaligned with the kind of work most established service providers are selling. When your offer is intimate, relational, and deeply personalised, the mechanics of cold lead generation work against you not because the tactic is inherently bad, but because it targets people who are not yet problem-aware. And getting a non-problem-aware person to a discovery call takes a level of invisible labour that almost never converts at the rate it deserves.

The surgeon analogy is one of the most clarifying reframes in the episode. A surgeon does not go door-knocking to ask people if they need open-heart surgery. The people who know they need her are already out looking. Her job is to be findable, credible, and positioned as the obvious choice not to convince people they have a problem. If your current lead gen strategy has you doing the convincing work, you are working at the wrong end of the pipeline.

I also goes deep on a pattern I see repeatedly in established founders: leading with credentials instead of client problems. There is a version of positioning that says 'I have this methodology, I have these years of experience, here is my signature framework' and there is a version that says 'I work with established coaches who are doing everything right and still not getting past 10K months', and I know exactly what is running that pattern. The first version leads with the provider. The second version leads with the person. The difference in conversion is not subtle.

Underneath the tendency to lead with credentials, I name what is often actually happening: an embodiment gap. A part of the founder that is still trying to justify her price point, still proving worthiness, still not fully landed in her own unique authority. When that is the energy behind the outreach, it doesn't matter how good the script is. The frequency is the problem, and sophisticated buyers can feel it.

The Key Concept Deep Dive: What Actually Works, Attraction Over Chasing

The most important strategic shift in this episode is the move from chasing marketing to attraction marketing. Not the vague use of that phrase, but the specific, actionable version of it.

Attraction marketing, in my framing, means positioning yourself directly in front of people who are already problem-aware. The woman who is googling at 2 AM is not googling 'how do I grow my business.' She is googling 'why do I keep hitting the same ceiling no matter what I do' or 'how do I stop being the bottleneck in my own business' or 'why does my revenue not match my expertise'. She has the problem. She is already in motion. Your job is to be what she finds when she goes looking.

This has enormous implications for content strategy, for offer positioning, and for where you invest your energy. A small amount of budget behind a highly focused content plan that speaks directly to your client's highest value problem will outperform hours of cold outreach, every single time, at this level. But only if the foundations are in place: a dialled-in offer, a precise problem statement, and messaging that speaks to the specific emotional reality of your ideal client not the vague, generalised version of her problem.

I also name the Instagram SEO opportunity that most coaches are underutilising. With search now integrated into Instagram captions, every piece of content you publish is a potential touchpoint for a problem-aware person actively searching for what you do. This is long-term evidence-building. It compounds. And it means your content is working for you even when you are not actively looking for clients.

On discovery calls, the reframe is important: they are not for selling. By the time the right person gets on a call with you, most of the selling has already happened through your content, your positioning, and the problem-aware journey you have been guiding them through. If people are not booking calls, the leak is upstream. It is in what you are putting out, who you are speaking to, and whether you are leading from certainty or from the anxiety of needing clients this month.

That last piece is the identity and strategy intersection I return to throughout. The frequency you lead from is legible. Not in a woo-woo way, in a very real, felt-sense way that sophisticated buyers pick up on instantly. Leading from 'I need to fill my programme' lands differently than leading from 'I know exactly who I help and I know exactly what becomes possible for her'. The words can be identical. The conversion is not.

Resources and Links Mentioned

The Vault (Methodology library, Self-paced)

Frequency First Business (Cohort opens 25 May)

Scaling Capacity Diagnostic

Transcript Excerpt

The following is transcribed from approximately 07:08 in the episode:

"Imagine a surgeon going to your door asking people if they need surgery. The people who don't need that surgeon don't even know that they need her yet. The people who do know that they need her are already out actively looking for someone at their level. They need to find her. She doesn't need to convince them that they need open heart surgery."

Continuing from approximately 10:30:

"I help coaches scale to six figures using my signature framework versus leading with your client's highest value problems. Like, I work with established coaches who are doing everything right, but still not getting past 10K months no matter what they do, and I know exactly what's running that pattern. There is a difference. The second one calls out exactly the pain growth that that particular person with that audience has."

Continuing from approximately 17:40:

"If your content is doing the problem awareness work for you before the discovery call even happens, by the time the right person is on a call with you, they should already feel like they know exactly who you are and why you are the one. Discovery calls aren't really, in my opinion, discovery calls aren't for selling. You've done most of the selling job before they get on that call."

Related Episodes

Ep 202: Why They Loved Your Content and Hired Someone Else

Ep 204: Tall Poppy Syndrome and Your Nervous System

Ep 207: Why Free Isn't Free: The Truth About Live Launching